Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
DiCarlos Original Pizza
Garden Salad
Salami Cheese Hoagie
Ham Provolone Hoagie
About
Paul's Pizza
Welcome to Paul's Pizza, a hidden gem located at 224 N 4th St, Toronto, OH. This delightful pizzeria has carved out a special place in the hearts of locals and visitors alike, thanks to its unique take on a classic dish—pizza. With a reputation that extends beyond the borders of Southern Ohio, Paul's Pizza is best known for its signature DiCarlos Original Pizza, which is a must-try for anyone seeking a taste of authenticity and tradition.
One of the standout features of Paul's Pizza is its specialty offerings, including:
- DiCarlos Original Pizza with three toppings: $10.50
- White Pizza: $11.50
- BLT Pizza: $11.50
But don’t overlook the sides and salads! Complement your pizza with a Garlic Sauce Side or Sub Sauce for just $0.50 each, and be sure to try their salads, such as the Garden Salad: $5.50 and Antipasto Salad: $7.00.
What makes Paul's Pizza truly special is the bake process that energizes the pizza experience. Customers rave about the stunning crust and savory sauce, with many noting that the cheese and pepperoni retain a delightful freshness. Joshua S, a satisfied patron, shares his initial surprise at the cooking method, but now, he can't get enough of the delicious investment he makes whenever he visits his fiancée's family. He's right—this level of flavor and quality is hard to come by, especially at such a competitive price.
Mark Phillips and others confirm that the attention to detail, such as crisping up the bottom of the pizza, sets Paul's Pizza apart from the rest. The friendly crew ensures your pizza is always ready promptly, another aspect that keeps guests coming back week after week. As BJ Holmes learned, you can even request a Take-N-Bake option, so you can enjoy fresh pizza right from your oven even hours after purchasing it.
In conclusion, Paul's Pizza isn't just a restaurant; it’s an experience that invites you back home, time after time. With many customers left praising their perfect square pizza, I can wholeheartedly recommend you visit this pizzeria. Whether you're a lifelong local or just passing through, make it a point to indulge in what truly is "some of the best square pizza" around!
For orders or inquiries, give them a ring at (740) 537-5555, and be prepared to be delighted.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Very unique pizza. Im not from southern Ohio so when I first experienced this pizza with my gfnow wife I was a little confused as to why the cheese and pepperoni werent cooked. However, Ive come to love this pizza and we make it a priority to order 2 sheets anytime we come down to visit her family to bring back with us. The crust is simply unbelievable and the sauce is outstanding. They also seem to be one of the few places where you can still get a decently priced pizza. If I ordered the same pizza in NEO it would cost me 4 times as much. I highly recommend dicarlos. ”
“ Excellent pizza shop in Toronto. The guy that is always cooking at night takes the pizza off the pan and puts in oven to crisp up the bottom, and this makes the pizza. ”
“ These guys rock. Im an outoftowner who misses the crunch and the great taste of Dicarlos. I asked these guys to sell me a TakeNBake so I could finish baking it and preparing at home in Akron. They completely squared me away. Its two days later and the Dicarlos pizza tastes like its fresh from the oven because its fresh from my oven Get you some of that next time youre in TTown. Thanks Guys! ”
“ I have had this pizza twice in the last week. Seriously, some of the best square pizza Ive ever had. Consistently perfect every time. ”
“ No other pizza tastes quite like DiCarlos. Plenty of cheese, and a nice crunch on the crust. Our family enjoys it at least once a week. Friendly crew. If you call and order it is ready when they give you a time. ”
“ Definitely my favorite. Best pizza in the entire area. I eat it quite often. ”
“ Pizza was delicious. I do sometimes like mine a little crunchy but it was still delicious and I recommend to anyone who hasnt tried it. I asked for extra cheese on the side and they very much gave me extra cheese on the side lol and if in area I would get it again ”
“ Ive been searching for a restaurant in the surrounding area, stupid Ville, Ohio, and Toronto, Ohio. I found this restaurant, and let me tell you, their hoagie is the best Ive ever had in Ohio. I had to drive to Pittsburgh, as Im from South Park Suburbs of Pittsburgh, and thats the only area that I can have found good Italian hoagies. Now Pauls Pizza is my go to place from now on. Friendly and great food. I highly recommend this Pizza joint for your enjoyment! Five Stars. ”